CECAN Short Course: Evaluating Complex Interventions with Process Tracing and Bayesian Updating
Blog
CECAN Seminar: What Works at the Nexus? Evidence, Policy and the Prospects for Transdisciplinary Research
At all levels of government, the ecosystem of institutions and individuals engaged in expert advice and evidence-informed policymaking is more diverse than ever before.
Agriculture Fit For A Complex World
To say that we live in a complex world is, in a very general sense, rather banal and uninteresting being neither particularly illuminating nor especially profound. But, scratch beneath the surface, and an acknowledgement of that complexity can be revelatory.
CECAN Seminar: Complexity, Power and Evidence in the UK Healthcare Sector: A Case Study of E-Health Research
The CECAN team would like to extend thanks to Professor Trish Greenhalgh from the University of Oxford, who kindly gave an energetic, thought provoking and highly logical seminar on evaluating e-health research.
Why We Need Network Analysis to Understand the Future of Economics
Network analysis is the method of the future. That is not only – certainly not primarily – because we are ever more connected in some superficial social-media driven internet sort of way. All of that may be fascinating (and certainly can be analysed using network analysis), but it is not fundamental to our existence as humans – we existed before Facebook, we will exist after it is gone
CECAN Complexity in Evaluation Workshop: What we Did and What we Learned
The first of two blogs following this event, from the perspective of the lead facilitator, Dr Paul Brand
Why Carry Out Economic Evaluation?
I have only recently joined the small economic research consultancy Simetrica. Before this I spent 16 years in the Government Economic Service, starting as an economic advisor in DTI in 2000 (now known as BEIS). I first worked on employment policy and one of my main tasks was to produce Impact Assessments for new employment regulation using the tools of Cost Benefit Analysis (CBA).
Access to Data is Crucial
CECAN is exploring how evaluation of policy can better inform the impact those policies have and assess the extent to which these have been successful. In order to do this, access to data is crucial, yet can at times be problematic. CECAN’s Knowledge Integrator, Candice Howarth met Emma Uprichard and Robert MacKay from the Centre and based at the University of Warwick and asked them over a series of emails to explain what the implications of some of these challenges are.
Aligning Policy and Evidence for the Age of Complexity
As the world changes in complex and unpredictable ways, Government is changing too. As it does so, the need grows for policy-making and the evidence that informs it to be alive and responsive to the increasing pervasiveness of complexity. In public service systems the increase in complexity often means that no single institution is ever ‘in charge’ or has direct control over how changes unfold.
Complexity High on the Agenda at the EES 2016 Biannual Conference
Maastricht was the location of this year’s European Evaluation Society (EES) conference over a sunny week in late September. At the end of first day, we were treated to a civic reception in the building in which the Maastricht treaty was signed in 1992, bringing up mixed emotions for some of us.
CECAN Seminar: Complexity, Power and Evidence in the UK Healthcare Sector – A Case Study of E-Health Research
Linear models of research and research impact are being replaced in the social sciences with dynamic ones that emphasise the complexity of interactions and non-linear chains of causation.
Likelihoods
The scope of the CECAN project runs wide as well as deep; complexity in the energy, water, environment and food domain would most immediately be thought to arise from the physical systems at the nexus core. Yes, complexity in weather systems, biological populations spring quickly and easily to mind as do the ‘user level’ human interactions with these systems and other local and global physical systems.
Micro-Simulation Seminar from Professor Peter Davis
Huge thanks to Professor Peter Davis who gave an engaging, humorous and thought provoking seminar at BEIS in Whitehall, on micro-simulation techniques for policy making.
Is Policy Evaluation Fit For Purpose?
By Roger Highfield, Director of External Affairs of the Science Museum, member of the Royal Society’s Science Policy Advisory Group. To tackle climate change, ecosystem destruction and the many daunting issues facing humanity we need not only to draw on science and engineering but also develop policies that can change the behaviour of 7.5 billion people.
CECAN Launch Event: Policy Evaluation For A Complex World
CECAN’s team were thrilled to host their official launch event at St Martin in the Fields Hall, London on 13th September 2016.
CEP Undertaking Meta-Evaluation of Past Policy Evaluations
As part of CEP’s role as a partner in CECAN, CEP is carrying out a meta-evaluation of a sample of the evaluation projects it has undertaken over the last 10 years.
Introducing Adam Hejnowicz – New Postdoc Researcher at University of York
Introducing the newest member of the CECAN team based at The University of York – Adam Hejnowicz has joined as a CECAN postdoctoral researcher.
Agent Based Modelling Course a Great Success
Professor Nigel Gilbert, Dr Lynne Hamill and Nicolas Payette delivered an intensive one day workshop in Agent Based Modelling, to a group of economists from UK Government on 3rd August.
CECAN Seminar: Evaluating Policy Scenarios with Micro-Simulation
As practitioners of “public social science” we all wish to contribute to the evaluation and development of policy.
CECAN Seminar: Policy Making Using Modelling in a Complex World
How do we use policy modelling in a complex world? Professor Bruce Edmonds explored this challenging question in CECAN’s second seminar on 18th July.
After the Brexit vote: What Next for the UK’s Environment?
This post is by Andy Jordan, Charlotte Burns and Viviane Gravey. They recently co-led an expert reviewof the environmental implications of Brexit funded by the UK in a Changing Europe Initiative.
CECAN Seminar: Revaluation – Measuring Paradigm Shift
23rd June 2016 will go down in history as a very difficult day in Westminster – Brexit Day. Nonetheless, Andrew Darnton and Andrew Harrison boldly produced an engaging and thought provoking complexity seminar in Whitehall.
How Should Academics Interact with Policy Makers? Lessons on Building a Long-term Advocacy Strategy
What can academics learn from how civil society organisations and NGOs approach policy impact? Julia Himmrich argues that academics have a lot to gain from embracing the practices of long-term advocacy. Advocacy is about establishing relationships and creating a community of experts both in and outside of government who can give informed input on policies.
Reflections on Language and Complexity
When I turned up at the CECAN Evaluation and Complexity workshop this week it was my first day back at work after a holiday in Crete, an experience that I thought might have put me in the right frame of mind. Being the non-scientist in a roomful of scientists often seems like being in a foreign country where I only speak a few words of the language.
Should Academics be Expected to Change Policy? Six Reasons Why it is Unrealistic for Research to Drive Policy Change.
UK social scientists feel a growing pressure to achieve policy change. In reality, this process is more complex than it sounds. James Lloyd looks at six reasons that limit the impact research can have on policy change. None of this should suggest that academic researchers shouldn’t seek to influence policymaking. But more consideration is needed on how best academic evidence can leverage the real-world nature of policymaking.
The Science of Using Research
Governments all over the world invest large sums of public money into producing knowledge that helps them understand their countries’ complex socioeconomic issues. This knowledge, in the form of research, can be used to formulate potential solutions through public policies and programmes.
CECAN Workshop: Complexity in Evaluation
This 2 day residential workshop, conducted under the Chatham House Rule, will bring together evidence teams, policy makers, policy analysts, complexity scientists, evaluation experts and experts in Nexus subjects.
CECAN Showcase Event: Policy Evaluation for A Complex World
This event will entertain, engage and excite anyone with an interest in improving methods of policy evaluation across the energy, environment and food Nexus.
Clearing the Fog
Development actors facing pressure to provide more rigorous assessments of their impact on policy and practice need new methods to deliver them. There is now a broad consensus that the traditional counterfactual analysis leading to the assessment of the net effect of an intervention is incapable of capturing the complexity of factors at play in any particular policy change.
CECAN Seminar: Policy Making Using Modelling in a Complex World
The consequences of complexity in the real world are discussed together with some meaningful ways of understanding and managing such situations.